or maybe the Sheriff for some seduction and betrayal--I would put S1 ad S4 Peter, Kate and Gerard, hell even Victoria Argent in the bad guy category but the Sheriff? I know there are fic writers who like to put him in the bad parent/abusive alcoholic role, but to me, he always came across as a loving/worried father who's out of his depth dealing with his much smarter son. Then again, that's what Rare Pairs is for :):)